Wednesday, April 05, 2017

The Reform Jewish Movement: "Liberalism-as-Judaism"


Why does a 3rd generation Temple Israel Reform Jew take an associate membership at an Orthodox synagogue? To get his spirituality back.
There is a school of thought within the Union of Reform Judaism (URJ) that Reform Judaism is nothing more (or less) than the American liberal political agenda, including the advocacy - in the name of Judaism and "Prophetic Ethics" - of liberal fashionable political ideas. The beginnings of this were in the New Deal era, when American Jewish support for Franklin D. Roosevelt was nearly unanimous. It continued after World War II.
 The "Liberalism as Judaism" School argued that all of Judaism and Jewish tradition could be boiled down into a search for civil "justice" and secular "freedom". Since it was axiomatic, in the eyes of Jewish liberals, that the liberal political agenda was synonymous with justice, freedom, and righteousness and that the opponents of liberalism were evil and unjust; "Judaism" itself could be conscripted in the cause of promoting liberal partisanship.
Jewish liberalism was never based upon any serious study of social science methodologies and tools of analysis, but rather upon self-righteousness, compassionate posturing, and the appealing to smug moral high-mindedness. Jewish community leaders and liberal Rabbis have no training whatsoever in policy analysis, economics, statistics or accounting. Their liberalism is based on making themselves feel righteous and accepted, not on resolving real-world problems.

This “liberalism equals Reform Judaism” has had a profound effect on the small but growing minority of politically conservative members of at Temple Israel and across the URJ. Going to Friday night services to hear sermons FOR gun control or AGAINST President Trump’s proposed immigration policy may play well to the majority, but it alienates those who are politically conservative realists. Lord Acton said it best - “The one pervading evil of democracy is the tyranny of the majority.” Well, the conservatives are feeling a bit abused by the tyranny of the liberal majority. Maybe instead of Temple Israel only “reaching out” to the Muslim and Christian communities it should consider reaching out to it’s conservative membership. A house of worship should be a haven for spirituality. It should not be an invasion of one’s sensibilities.

The hypocrisy of the “Liberal Reform Movement” is also a bit hard to swallow. The “Reform Left” has no problem criticizing POTUS Trump for a sexist comment he made 10 years earlier (on a bus that was secretly recorded), yet public statements in a YouTube speech by a Yale educated Muslim Professor (Yasir Qadhi) invited to speak at Memphis’s Temple Israel states that “Jews and Christians are filthy and that their lives and property can be taken in jihad by the Muslims ” – and it is overlooked as a youthful indiscretion.

I am not quitting Temple Israel. I am a 3rd generation member, the next two generations of Fargotstein’s are members there, generations of my family are buried there, and I will be buried there. I will, however, continue to stand up for Temple to become the inclusive, spiritual political free zone that it needs to be in order to return to it’s mission of Jewish spirituality, rather than the religion of liberalism.


No comments: